

A closer read of the Supreme Court’s judgment on YES Bank’s ₹8,415 crore Additional Tier 1 (AT1) bonds shows that the court was not deciding whether these bonds could be written down, but whether the action was carried out in accordance with the regulatory framework.
AT1 bonds are perpetual, high-yield debt instruments issued by banks under Basel III norms to strengthen their core capital and absorb losses during financial distress.
“The question is the manner in which it was done, de hors the Master Circular and the Information Memoranda,” the judgment by justices Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih said in the judgment.
YES Bank was rescued under a government- and RBI-backed reconstruction scheme after the lender faced near financial collapse amid mismanagement, rising bad loans and governance issues.
There are four key points the SC highlighted.
1. The draft scheme included a provision to write down the AT1 bonds. But that provision was absent from the final scheme, notified on March 13, 2020.
The court said it had “good reasons to infer that the Central Government had taken a conscious decision to exclude the clause permitting writing down of the AT-1 Bonds from the Reconstruction Scheme, based on consideration of the objections lodged."
The administrator’s decision to write off the bonds the following day effectively reversed that outcome. The court held that the administrator had acted under an “erroneous impression or mistaken belief” that he retained the authority to write down the instruments even after the scheme had come into force.
The judgment described the action as “an impermissible act and ultra vires the Master Circular read with the Reconstruction Scheme”.
This finding also disposed of the argument that the administrator’s residual powers under the reconstruction scheme allowed him to proceed with the write-off. The court accepted that the scheme preserved certain residual powers, but said a general provision could not confer a specific power that was absent.
A power not specifically conferred cannot be implicitly vested through a general, omnibus savings clause.
The bench
AT1 bonds are perpetual instruments that carry high risk and typically offer higher returns than bank deposits. They do not have a fixed maturity date and can absorb losses when specified conditions are met.
2. Under the terms of the YES Bank bonds, the pre-specified trigger was reached when the bank’s Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) capital ratio fell below 6.125% of risk-weighted assets for the relevant period. The CET1 capital ratio is a financial metric that measures a bank's core equity capital against its total risk-weighted assets to test its solvency and ability to withstand financial stress. The court noted that YES Bank’s CET1 ratio stood at just 0.6% as of December 31, 2019, against a requirement of 7.375%.
The threshold had therefore been breached well before the reconstruction scheme was notified. Yet the bank did not exercise its option to convert or write down the bonds at that stage.
“Thus, despite having the option but not the obligation to convert or write down the bonds, YES BANK chose not to. We do not intend to question such wisdom,” the court said.
The court found that the decision by the relevant authorities to reconstruct YES Bank had activated the point-of-non-viability trigger. But the write-off was ordered by the administrator, rather than by the RBI exercising the authority specified in the bond documents and the Master Circular.
The Administrator could not have assumed the regulatory role of the RBI and exercise a power which it did not have at all.
The bench
The court reached this conclusion after examining Section 36ACA of the Banking Regulation Act, under which the administrator had been appointed. The provision allowed him to exercise the powers, functions and duties of the bank’s board. It did not, in the court’s reading, transfer to him the distinct regulatory power assigned to the RBI.
In other words, the Supreme Court said the administrator’s appointment to run the bank did not make him interchangeable with the regulator for every purpose. The fact that a write-down might have been necessary to stabilise the bank could not substitute for the authority and procedure required by the rules.
3. A clause in the RBI’s Master Circular on Basel III capital regulations said AT1 instruments had to be converted or permanently written down “before amalgamation/reconstitution”.
YES Bank, the RBI and the Union government argued that reconstruction was a continuing process and that the administrator’s authority to write down the bonds remained available until the obligations under the scheme had been completed.
But the court rejected that interpretation. It held that “before reconstitution” meant before the reconstruction scheme came into force, not at any point while its provisions were still being implemented.
“The preposition ‘before’ can only mean before the Reconstruction Scheme takes effect,” the judgment said. It added that although the effects of a reconstruction scheme might run for years, that did not empower the relevant authority to write down AT1 bonds at any point during that period.
The scheme came into force on March 13, 2020, while the administrator ordered the write-off on March 14. On the court’s interpretation, the prescribed window had already closed.
The judgment also referred to the treatment of bonds during the reconstruction of Lakshmi Vilas Bank, where a similar write-down took place a day before the amalgamation scheme came into force. The court noted that the reason for not following the same course in YES Bank’s case remained unexplained.
The judgment reinforces that even during a banking crisis, the powers of the RBI, the Administrator and the government must be exercised within their respective legal limits.
Sonam Chadwani, managing partner, KS Legal & Associates
"For investors, the decision is significant because it shows that the contractual risk associated with AT-1 bonds does not automatically eliminate the requirement to follow the applicable law," Chadwani added, speaking to The Financial Standard.
4. The judgment is also sharply critical of the way the episode was handled by YES Bank, the RBI and the administrator. The court questioned why the RBI had allowed YES Bank’s CET1 ratio to fall to 0.6% and why investors were left exposed to what it described as administrative lapses.
“The RBI was a mere bystander, allowing the CET1 ratio of YES BANK to drop to an astonishing low of 0.6%,” the bench said.
It added that “to have the investors at the receiving end of the administrative lapses would be highly unfair”.
The court also raised concerns about YES Bank’s sale of AT1 bonds directly to individual investors. It noted that the RBI’s Master Circular specified classes of investors, including mutual funds and insurance companies, to whom such instruments could be offered.
The court found that YES Bank had actively offered the high-risk securities to individuals in violation of the circular. It said “a tighter scrutiny ought to have been exercised before luring individual investors to such high-risk securities”.
To sum up, while the court accepted that writing down the bonds might have served a purpose in reviving YES Bank, it did not accept that this purpose could override the process prescribed for doing so.