Yes Bank AT1 bond saga: investors push for clarity on payment of dues

The next coupon payment of the 9.5% bond series is due on 23 December
Customers gather around a Yes Bank branch
Bondholders have sought a clear timeline for payment of duesRavi Choudhary
Published on: 

Yes Bank’s aggrieved retail Additional Tier 1 (AT-1) bondholders have sought a meeting with Vinay Tonse, MD and CEO of Yes Bank, to draw up a clear plan for repayment of their dues.

In a letter dated November 3, the bondholders have sought a clear timeline for payment of dues after the bank missed the last coupon payment date of October 19. They have asked the bank to adhere to the Supreme Court order and clear the dues without delay.

AT-1 bonds are a type of perpetual bond instrument that carries no maturity date. These papers typically offer higher interest rates but carry higher risks.

The Supreme Court on October 16 upheld the Bombay High Court order which quashed a decision of the Yes Bank administrator to write off additional tier-1 bonds worth ₹8,415 crore in March 2020. A bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih said, "We see no reason to interfere with the impugned judgement. The appeals are dismissed."

"Putting the investors to such uncalled-for risk could have well been avoided. The purpose of the AT-1 bonds is imperative: it acts as a safety barrier to the bank from collapsing altogether. That purpose could have been served had RBI and Yes Bank acted in accordance with the terms of the Master Circular."

According to the bondholders' association, the settlement of the bond and coupon rate together amounts to ₹1,500 crore. The next date of coupon payment of 9.5% bond series is due on 23 December 2026.

“If the bank disputes its liability, it must provide its specific contractual and legal reasoning rather than a general reference to coupon discretion. The payment of the annual coupon rate shall remain unaffected by the outcome of the coupon payment,” reads the letter addressed to Tonse.

The Financial Standard has reviewed a copy of the letter.

Further, the bondholders have asked Yes Bank to clarify its position on the implementation of the judgment and whether the Bank accepts the same.

“We have won the case in the Supreme Court; now we want our money back in one tranche along with the coupon payments. We cannot trust the bank with staggered payment,” said Saurabh Mehta, who leads the AT-1 bondholders' association, which has nearly 160 members.

Bondholders have urged the bank to deal directly with the association rather than carry out correspondence with Axis Trustee.

In the letter, bondholders seek to know whether the bank has initiated the restoration process and relevant exchange records. “We expect a dated implementation plan, not another statement that the matter is being evaluated,” the letter added.

The regulatory record is particularly telling. Figures recorded in SEBI's adjudication proceedings, based on information supplied by the bank, show that 1,311 of 1,346 individual investors who purchased the bonds were existing Yes Bank customers. Of these, 789 held fixed deposits with the bank, while 277 prematurely closed fixed deposits to invest in AT-1 bonds. These figures raise a fundamental question about the bank's conduct towards its own customers.

The Bombay High Court judgment dated 20 January 2023 recorded the bondholders' submissions concerning the sale of AT-1 bonds to existing fixed-deposit holders and the use of relationship managers for the distribution of these instruments.

The Supreme Court, which upheld the Bombay High Court ruling dismissing Yes Bank's petition, had observed that Yes Bank had actively offered these instruments to individual investors in violation of the applicable RBI Master Circular, which disallowed the bonds from being sold to retail investors.

The court also observed that tighter scrutiny ought to have been exercised while selling these bonds.

“Your customers entrusted their savings to the bank. The bank had an existing relationship with them and used its own distribution channels to offer these high-risk instruments. Some customers broke fixed deposits to make these investments. These were not merely transactions on a screen,” the letter added.

AT-1 bonds were allegedly marketed to investors as a "Super FD", with an interest rate only 0.5% higher than that offered on existing fixed deposits. “SEBI's proceedings have also brought to light the role of relationship-manager targets and incentives in driving distribution, alongside deficiencies in the communication and understanding of the risks associated with these instruments,” the letter added.