Rise in loan default signals stress build-up in banking system

According to Arcil chief, the banking system is sitting on nearly ₹24 lakh crore of stressed assets
A man leaning forward carrying a car on his back
Josue Sanchez/Unsplash
Published on: 

A rise in the share of special mention accounts (SMA) of banks signals a gradual build-up of stress in the Indian banking system, suggesting these loans could fall into the bad loan category in the event of prolonged economic distress.

A special mention account refers to a loan account that indicates overdue payments before the loan actually turns into a non-performing asset (NPA) after the 90-day period. For instance, if loans are overdue by 60 days, the account falls into the SMA-2 category. Such accounts flag early signs of financial stress.

Worried over the fate of such loans, banks have now put a part of ₹7.7 lakh crore worth of SMA-2 loans on the block for sale to asset reconstruction companies (ARCs), said Phanindranath Kakarla, managing director and CEO of Asset Reconstruction Company India Ltd (Arcil). Around 87% of the loans are in the retail and SME categories. This category of loans has gone up by 35.30% compared with the year-ago period, according to the latest data released by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI).

According to the Arcil chief, the banking system is sitting on ₹24 lakh crore of stressed assets, including the NPA pool, overdue amounts, write-offs and fresh bad loan additions every quarter.

Loans that are overdue by more than 30 days (SMA-1) and those overdue by 60 days (SMA-2) make up around ₹3.4 lakh crore, the RBI data showed. The SMA-2 accounts have a higher probability of falling into the NPA category.

“Banks have started showcasing SMAs to the ARCs for faster resolutions and maintenance of cleaner books. So, there are enough assets for the ARCs to acquire and resolve,” Kakarla said.  

ARCs like Arcil are in the business of purchasing bad loans from banks and other financial institutions at a discount and then pooling such assets as marketable securities to either sell to other buyers or recover from end-borrowers. During the first half of the current fiscal year, Arcil acquired ₹1,707 crore of bad loans, up 18% from ₹1,445 crore a year ago.

Large loan write-offs by Indian banks over the last decade have helped the system report lower NPA numbers, but that comes at a cost. Banks need to make 100% provisions on loans that are written off, which, in turn, impacts their profitability.

According to Kakarla, the stark ₹24 lakh crore figure is not visible on the books of banks because they have written off over ₹12 lakh crore over the last ten10 years.

“There have been continued fresh bad loan accretions and substantial write-offs, but the gross NPA stock has declined from its peak of over ₹10 lakh crore around 2017-18 to below ₹4 lakh crore now — or from more than 10% gross NPA to around 3.8% now,” said Ravi Ranjan, managing director in charge of stressed assets at State Bank of India (SBI). “This reflects a combination of improved credit underwriting, resolution and recovery efforts, upgradation of accounts, and balance-sheet clean-up through write-offs,” Ranjan said.

In the period that followed the global financial crisis, Indian banks engaged in a phase of loose lending that eventually led to a spike in stressed assets. This forced the RBI to initiate an asset quality review in 2015, which required banks to disclose large amounts of hidden bad loans. Banks resorted to large-scale loan write-offs to clean up their books. According to Arcil's Kakarla, total loan write-offs stood at ₹12.25 lakh crore, of which ₹5.8 lakh crore was from the retail and SME (small and medium enterprises) segments, while ₹6.4 lakh crore was from corporate bad loans.

As per the latest figures available, banks have pushed around 1.51 trillion accounts valued at ₹5.79 lakh crore in FY25 through various recovery mechanisms like lok adalats, SARFAESI, debt recovery tribunals, and the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC). The recovered amount stood at ₹1.04 lakh crore, or just 18% of what was put up for recovery.

“The true measure of success should be the recovery of economic value and reduction in credit losses rather than merely a reduction in reported NPAs," said Ranjan of SBI. "Overall, the system is remarkably clean now as far as bad assets are concerned."

Correction: An earlier version of the story read: "Worried over the fate of such loans, banks have now put at least ₹7.7 lakh crore worth of SMA-2 loans on the block ..."

This now been updated to: "...a part of ₹7.7 lakh crore worth of SMA-2 loans on the block for sale to asset reconstruction companies (ARCs)"