

Some British Scotch importers have allegedly misused the benefits of the India-UK free trade agreement (FTA) by manipulating customs classifications to secure lower tariffs, according to officials at the Ministry of Commerce. The government, however, assured the industry it will look into the matter and try to resolve the dispute at the earliest.
"The fact is they (UK importers) had classified the item under a particular HS code and even obtained a court order directing that it be classified under that code, where the applicable customs duty was lower. They were essentially shopping for the lowest possible duty rate,” said a government official on condition of anonymity.
Tariff shopping or HS code misdeclaration refers to the practice of deliberately classifying an imported product under a different Harmonised System (HS) code to gain an unfair advantage, usually by paying lower customs duties or bypassing import restrictions. HS codes are numerical classifications maintained by the World Customs Organization (WCO) to identify traded goods for customs, tariff, and trade statistics purposes.
Bottled Scotch, which is ready for consumption and does not require further processing in India, falls under one HS code, while concentrated whisky imported in bulk falls under a different code, said another official. The latter requires further processing before it can be sold as a finished product. The two categories attract different tariff rates even under the FTA. The dispute centres on the tariff classification of bulk Scotch imported in concentrated form into India.
“As soon as they started talking about the FTA, they quietly moved it back to the other one. There they would have got a lower rate,” the official said.
Indian Customs recently imposed an effective duty of 162.5% on bulk Scotch imports, instead of the 75% rate that importers expected under the India-UK trade agreement.
Trade experts have disputed the government's position, arguing that global trade rules require goods to be taxed based on their composition and nature when they cross the border, rather than what happens to them subsequently. They contend that diluting Scotch cannot change its customs classification. Even if a shipment fails to qualify as Scotch whisky, they argue, it would fall under the general category of spirits and not the 150% category for raw preparations used in making beverages.
Karthik Iyer, partner – Indirect Tax, Tax & Regulatory Advisory, BDO India, said, "The present controversy is fundamentally a customs classification issue arising in the implementation of the India-UK trade agreement."
According to Ajay Srivastava, a trade policy analyst and founder of the Global Trade Research Initiative, the General Rules for the Interpretation of the Harmonized System requires Customs to classify the liquid by what is in the container as it arrives at the border. If the liquid is already Scotch whisky, transporting it in large containers or adding water later before bottling does not change the nature of the product at the time of import, he said.
Scotch whisky imported in containers holding more than two litres qualifies for a 75% basic customs duty under the India-UK trade agreement. "To charge 150% by treating it as a preparation for making beverages, Customs must first show that the imported liquid falls outside the entire tariff category for spirits," said Srivastava.
Importers maintain that bulk Scotch imports should also qualify for preferential tariff concessions under the FTA. The government, however, maintains that such imports fall under a separate customs classification for alcoholic preparations used in manufacturing beverages.
Under the trade agreement, which came into force on July 15, India reduced import duties on Scotch whisky from 150% to 75% with immediate effect, with a phased reduction to 40% over 10 years. However, the FTA does not automatically extend the concession to bulk whisky concentrates, which are classified separately.
Tax experts cautioned that the outcome of the dispute could have significant working capital and compliance implications for the alcoholic beverages industry, particularly manufacturers dependent on imported Scotch inputs for domestic blending operations. The classification dispute has also led to consignments being held up at Indian ports.