A Huang-sized hole in the AI saga

The aura around Nvidia was central to that too-big-to-fail narrative. Huang’s fall has tarnished it
A photo of Jensen Huang
Jensen HuangReuters
Published on: 

A Huang-sized hole in the AI saga

If you needed a reminder on why monopolies are bad, the past fortnight would have served plenty.

Until October 29, when The New York Times published its bombshell report on Nvidia supreme leader Jensen Huang’s dalliance with alleged Chinese spy Alice Huang, the company’s control over 90% of the AI chip market – sized at $120 bn today and estimated to cross $1 tn in the next decade – evoked envy and awe. (Just as well, because the name Nvidia is a riff on Invidia, the Roman goddess of envy.)

But in the two weeks since the Times ripped open Huang’s bag of dirty secrets, the established order in the AI world has felt like it’s about to collapse.

Huang’s resignation following revelations of another extramarital affair, and reports of a possible third, has not just left a leadership hole in the company; it threatens a vacuum in the global AI industrial complex, almost entirely powered by Nvidia, which, in turn, was under the thumb of its rockstar ex-CEO.

Until now, the AI industry seemed to be mowing down everything in its path – including climate-minded naysayers – with brute force. Stijn Van Nieuwerburgh, a professor at Columbia Business School, said by late-last year, AI-related infrastructure investment was already driving nearly all observed US GDP growth. “We’d basically be in a recession right now without data centers. That’s how big AI is,” Van Nieuwerburgh said.

The aura around Nvidia was central to that too-big-to-fail narrative. Huang’s fall has tarnished it.

Markets have weathered the aftermath relatively well, with Nvidia rivals like AMD and Broadcom finding investor love. The bigger risk is policy. Governments and AI players across the world, including in India, are watching with trepidation if the US stance towards chip exports, already hawkish, turns even sterner. Trump at the wheel means no one knows.

Instability at the industry’s most powerful company comes after the Democratic win in the US midterms cast a cloud over the data centre boom. A wobbly Nvidia could further weaken the gangbusters AI story investors were gaga over.

The timing is complicated also because we are days from Anthropic’s IPO, billed as a blockbuster even at a reduced valuation of $1.4 tn from $2 tn. Nvidia has pledged a $10 bn investment in Anthropic through a private placement. While that deal may not be jeopardised just yet, the goings-on of the past two weeks could test market confidence more than Anthropic had anticipated.

The most consequential industry of our times could well be at an inflection point where it needs a talisman to rally around. Huang has hung that hope out to dry.