CLSA’s Alexander Redman sees India opportunity, flags equity dilution

Redman said India's dollar-denominated EPS had remained broadly flat over the preceding two years, partly because of dilution and the rupee's weakness
Alexander Redman, chief equity strategist, CLSA
Alexander Redman, chief equity strategist, CLSACLSA
Published on: 

Global brokerage CLSA has turned overweight on Indian equities after a period of significant underperformance against the Asia-Pacific market. Improving earnings revisions, a likely recovery in private consumption and the rupee’s valuation support the case for India, although persistent equity dilution remains a concern, Alexander Redman, chief equity strategist at CLSA, said at the brokerage’s 29th India Forum in Mumbai on November 16.

India underperformed the Asia-Pacific benchmark by 49% from August 2024 to mid-October. By mid-October 2026, it had given back the relative gains it had made against the region between 2021 and 2024, Redman said.

Foreign investors had sold around $64 bn of Indian equities, taking their ownership to the lowest level since 2010. India had also become the third-largest underweight market, on average, among 24 emerging markets tracked by dedicated emerging-market funds, he noted.

Redman said the rupee was the cheapest it had been in his career, which began in 1995, when measured against its long-term trend on a real effective exchange rate basis.

The case for a recovery rests partly on improving earnings revisions. Redman said revisions had picked up across sectors, although India had a long record of falling short of analysts’ initial higher earnings expectations. The country had delivered earnings per share (EPS) below those estimates 81% of the time over the past three decades, he said.

Private consumption, which had held back economic growth in recent years, is expected to recover and become a driver of growth again next year, supported by government measures, tax cuts and rural demand. India also has the highest credit growth in the region, he said.

Redman identified the increase in the number of shares in the market as a key factor weighing on earnings per share. The number of shares in the MSCI India index rose by an average of 8% annually between 2015 and 2025. This measure includes fresh issuance, primary and secondary offerings, rights issues and changes in index constituents.

While the pace of deal activity may have peaked, issuance equivalent to 1.3% of India's market capitalisation was still being added every 12 months, he said.

That’s a lot to absorb. India has been a victim of its own success.

Alexander Redman

The increase in share count can dilute per-share earnings even when aggregate corporate profits grow. Currency depreciation also affects returns for overseas investors. Redman said India's dollar-denominated EPS had remained broadly flat over the preceding two years, partly because of dilution and the rupee's weakness.

Redman said the rupee was the cheapest it had been in his career, which began in 1995, when measured against its long-term trend on a real effective exchange rate basis. He expects an improvement in India's external position, helped by easing oil prices, to support the currency.

On whether recent foreign buying represented a short-term reversal or a more durable reallocation to India. He said it was too early to tell. A sustained improvement in earnings and stability in the rupee would help determine whether the return of foreign investors lasted beyond a tactical trade.