Mid- and small-cap stocks continue to trade at a steep premium to large caps despite a prolonged correction in Indian equities, with domestic mutual fund flows helping sustain the valuation gap, according to a report by wealth management platform W by Groww.
The Nifty Midcap 150 traded at a 47% premium to the Nifty 50 in September, well above its 10-year average premium of 19%. The Nifty Smallcap 250 commanded a 34% premium, against its 10-year average discount of 11%, the report said.
The divergence is also evident in forward earnings multiples. Between September 2024 and September 2026, the Nifty 50’s forward price-to-earnings (P/E) multiple fell 29% to 17.6 times. The Nifty Midcap 150’s multiple declined 27% to 25.8 times, while the Nifty Smallcap 250’s fell just 6% to 23.6 times.
The Nifty spent 145 trading days below its 200-day moving average between February 27 and September 30, its eighth-longest such spell on record. It fell as much as 11.5% below the average, according to DSP Netra and W Research data.
Nirav Karkera, head of research and fund manager at W by Groww, attributed the weakness partly to a "global repricing of money", as rising long-term bond yields in the US and Japan made those markets more attractive relative to Indian assets.
Foreign portfolio investors (FPIs) sold ₹45,537 crore of Indian equities on exchanges in September. Japan’s 10-year government bond yield crossed 3% in September, its highest since 1996, while the US 10-year treasury yield touched 5.34% on October 1, the highest since 2002, the report said.
The Nifty has fallen for eight consecutive weeks, a streak seen only twice since 1990. Karkera said the decline had remained relatively shallow because earnings and book values continued to grow even as share prices stalled, while domestic flows absorbed some of the foreign selling.
Equity mutual funds received ₹38,307 crore in September, of which ₹16,873 crore, or 44%, went into small- and mid-cap funds.
Sahil Kapoor, head of products and market strategist at DSP Mutual Fund, described the market as "extremely bipolar" in a recent webinar. "One part of the market, which is small and mid-cap, is trading as if we are in a bull market, full-blown bull market," he said. "The current multiples are higher than they were in any other previous bull market."
By contrast, some private banks, consumer staples and IT companies are trading at valuations comparable to levels seen during the Covid-19 period or the 2008 global financial crisis, Kapoor said.
Mid-and small-cap stocks have gained 32% from their February 2025 lows, compared with about 15% for large caps, according to the W by Groww report.
Karkera favours large caps and recommends staggered investments over three months, while advising investors to be selective with mid- and small-cap stocks.
Karkera said FY27 earnings estimates for the Nifty remained broadly defensible, but depended on companies protecting margins as higher crude prices feed through to results. "The next two quarters will be decided by who can protect margins," he said.
Chemicals, paints, cement, automobiles and aviation face cost pressures. Oil marketing companies are also exposed if retail fuel prices remain frozen despite higher crude costs. A weak rural consumption could weigh on consumer staples, while IT companies need to deliver a recovery in revenue growth.
Private banks, capital-markets infrastructure, telecom, capital goods and power are better placed to support FY27 earnings, Karkera said.
He identified an easing of global pressures as the likeliest trigger for a sustained market recovery. Indicators to watch include Brent crude falling below $85 a barrel, the US 10-year Treasury yield moving decisively below 5.5% and sustained foreign buying, he said.