Tech stocks rebound, but fund managers remain wary

Nifty IT index gains 18% in a month, but revenue concerns persist
Image of a market chart
Most technology funds gained an average 12.8% in OctoberYashowardhan Singh/unspalsh
Published on: 

Mutual fund managers remain cautious on technology stocks despite a recent rebound, fearing that global headwinds could derail the improvement seen in revenues. Most technology funds gained an average of 12.8% in October, but the rally has done little to change fund managers' cautious outlook.

The sector came back into focus following a sell-off in global tech stocks and a recent rally in the Nifty IT index after months of underperformance. The index gained 18.06% over the past month and 4.87% over the past three months. However, it remains down 7.62% over the past year, according to Value Research data.

Technology funds, apart from pure-play Indian IT services companies, also have software, digital businesses, and other technology-oriented stocks in their portfolio, along with exchange-traded funds and index funds.

Fund managers see valuations of these firms as more reasonable now after a phase of prolonged underperformance. But they aren't sure how the recovery will pan out, with artificial intelligence (AI)-related disruption, pricing pressure and subdued technology spending continuing to cloud the outlook.

Shreyas Devalkar, fund manager and head - equities at Axis Mutual Fund, said the slowdown in growth of large Indian IT companies had been a concern even before the recent AI debate.

“Over the last three decades, the growth of large IT companies has come down from around 15% to 10%, and now to below 5%,” Devalkar said. He also pointed out that the moderation among large tech firms has been significant when compared with some fast-growing small and mid-sized companies.

However, the valuations are attractive, with the sector trading at around 15-18 times earnings. Dividend yields and depreciation of the rupee also augur well, as a weaker currency can help translate dollar-denominated revenue into higher rupee growth.

Yet, these factors alone do not make the sector a compelling long-term investment opportunity. Sahil Kapoor, head of products and market strategist at DSP Mutual Fund, said these improvements have to translate into stronger revenue growth. “That, I think, is still missing,” Kapoor said, adding that a slowdown in business fundamentals, earnings and margins can persist for some time.

Meanwhile, Sumanta Khan, fund manager at Edelweiss Mutual Fund, said the more immediate challenge for IT services companies was the productivity gains from AI, which could put pressure on billing rates and contract pricing.

“The real challenge for the IT services industry is productivity deflation. AI is bringing efficiency gains, and companies renewing contracts are trying to negotiate harder because they know that certain tasks can now be done more efficiently. This is putting pressure on pricing,” Khan added.