Binance episode vindicates RBI's stand on crypto

This also should remind the government to speed up crypto regulations
The logo of Binance behind two cryptocoins.
Representative imageKanchanara/unsplash
Published on: 

The Binance fiasco, involving $6.3 billion in funds, is the latest lesson for crypto investors that these instruments cannot be taken at face value as a means of parking their hard-earned money.

With no underlying assets or regulatory backing, virtual currencies can be likened to riding a tiger. There is imminent danger at all times. This is exactly what the central bank has been warning about all along.

Binance is not the first such case. Before this, the WazirX episode, in which a $235 million cyberattack in July 2024 wiped out a substantial portion of customer assets, exposed the vulnerabilities in crypto custody arrangements and the absence of a robust regulatory and investor-protection framework.

Although there is no official estimate, industry chatter suggests that India has around 90-100 million users in the crypto market, with an estimated market size of $9.13 billion.

In February 2022, the then Reserve Bank of India (RBI) governor Shaktikanta Das famously said cryptocurrencies had no underlying value and were “not even a tulip”. His reference was to the Tulip Mania of the 1630s, when the Dutch Republic experienced a massive obsession with newly introduced, multi-coloured tulip bulbs.

Prices soared to absurd heights and, at the peak of the frenzy, a single rare tulip bulb could cost more than a luxury house or a lifetime's salary for a skilled worker. Then came the crash. In 1637, buyers suddenly refused to show up at an auction. Panic set in, the market collapsed completely within days, and thousands of investors were left holding near-worthless flower bulbs.

Das' reference to tulips was in the context of the rising popularity of cryptocurrencies in India. In the post-Covid era, youngsters flocked to crypto exchanges such as Binance, WazirX and CoinDCX to buy crypto coins that sprang up like mushrooms, often from unknown makers with fancy names and themes.

Even as the frenzy was building, the RBI repeatedly cautioned against the crypto mania, even calling for an outright ban, citing the risks. The regulator's concerns were valid. Although there is no official estimate, industry chatter suggests that India has around 90-100 million users in the crypto market, with an estimated market size of $9.13 billion.

What adds to the risks for investors is the lack of regulation. In the event of a crisis, such as the Binance episode, there is no regulator investors can turn to, either in India or abroad. India only taxes crypto profits but does not regulate the sector.

The country has allowed cryptocurrencies to exist in a tricky zone since the Supreme Court in 2018 struck down the Reserve Bank of India's (RBI) policies that effectively banned them. Later, a 2021 draft legislation to ban private cryptocurrencies was never introduced in Parliament, and a discussion paper on the matter has been deferred repeatedly. In effect, cryptos are neither fully regulated nor accorded legal-tender status in India.

In short, the Binance episode is another reminder to the Indian government of why it should urgently bring in regulations for crypto assets. It is also a big red flag for investors to stay away from such assets until regulations are in place.