

There is no other way to say it — the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) may have already found itself at the wrong end of the rupee rescue battle, if one goes by the numbers so far.
Consider the numbers. The RBI has mobilised $143.6 bn through special dollar deposits from Indians abroad to shore up the rupee. Of this, FCNR(B) deposits alone accounted for $132.98 bn. Economists estimate that the central bank has deployed around $75 bn–$80 bn through spot dollar sales and dollar-rupee swaps.
That is almost half the money raised. But the local currency remains caught in the maze of high crude oil prices and foreign fund outflows. The scheme was launched on June 8, but the rupee hasn’t gained much since then and has stayed in the range of 94.35-94.95. In other words, largely within a tight range. The RBI has certainly brought in some breathing space for the rupee, but the question is how long it can sustain that.
Despite these measures, we see limited room for sustained rupee appreciation on grounds of manufacturing/trade competitiveness.
Radhika Rao, senior economist, Singapore-based DBS Bank
“A challenging portfolio flows outlook leaves the door open to further gradual rupee depreciation subject to global developments, with high sensitivity to oil price movements and risk sentiments,” Rao said in a research note dated October 16.
Rao is right. The RBI does not have the luxury of influencing either global crude oil prices or foreign investor sentiment. Its actions are limited to spot market interventions using borrowed dollars. And the RBI has done what it could.
But this borrowed money could give the central bank some sleepless nights. The RBI has absorbed the hedging cost of FCNR(B) deposits and has promised to return the dollars when these deposits mature. If the rupee weakens against the dollar, say past 100, the central bank will have to bear that loss.
The RBI probably hoped to repeat the playbook of 2013 when a similar FCNR(B) scheme was launched to save a falling rupee. Back then, the RBI had mobilised about $34 bn, helping the rupee recover nearly 10% from its record low. This time, the RBI raised $143.6 bn, but the rupee's gains have been far less convincing.
The fundamental question is whether the breathing space bought by the RBI can be used by the country to attract sustainable foreign fund flows.
On Thursday (October 22), at 1.55 pm, the rupee was trading at 94.76 against the dollar, up 0.48% from the previous close. This was probably buoyed by foreign fund flows to participate in the Jio IPO. But this may not sustain once the momentum fades.
Besides the FCNR(B) scheme, the RBI has launched a mix of initiatives to curb speculation and limit foreign fund outflows. The RBI has done its part and will probably do more through conventional measures to support the domestic currency.
For the rupee to strengthen, the central bank may have to raise rates again to narrow the interest rate differential with the US. But none of this may be enough to save the rupee. The fundamental question is whether the breathing space bought by the RBI can be used by the country to attract sustainable foreign fund flows.
The answer partly lies with Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman. If the finance minister complements the central bank’s actions with a cut in the long-term capital gains tax (LTCG) rate, a pressing demand from investors, foreign investors may have an incentive to invest in Indian equities. The country also needs to think of ways to reduce its dependence on crude oil imports. At present, India imports around 85% of its domestic oil requirements from a clutch of foreign countries, draining dollar reserves.
The RBI cannot continue selling dollars to buy time for the rupee, as this will erode forex reserves and take away the central bank’s firepower to deal with a future exigency. If the rupee fails to gain ground soon, the very logic of the RBI’s rupee rescue playbook will be questioned, costs apart.