SC’s Yes Bank AT1 bonds write-off isn’t fair play

Big news for Yes Bank shareholders who fought a long battle, but at the risk of eroding RBI's authority
A woman walks out of a branch of Yes Bank in New Delhi
Reuters
Published on: 

Six years after Yes Bank's Additional Tier 1 bonds were written off following a Reserve Bank of India (RBI)-guided reconstruction scheme, Yes Bank bond holders are finally getting their money back. The Supreme Court has quashed the write-down, upholding a Bombay High Court order.

For those not familiar, AT1 bonds are perpetual, unsecured hybrid debt instruments issued by banks to strengthen their core capital base under Basel III norms. These bonds have no fixed maturity date. If a bank fails financially, these bonds can be permanently written down or converted into equity.

So why do people still buy them? The answer lies in the lucrative interest rates they offer.

Bank executives often do not explain the risks to customers looking for a windfall while selling the product. The party goes on till the going is good, but all hell breaks loose in the event of a failure.

That’s what happened with some Yes Bank investors. AT1 bonds were allegedly sold by Yes Bank executives to many Yes Bank fixed deposit holders in the guise of Super FDs. But that’s not the case with all investors. Most investors, mainly institutional investors, understood the risk but bought the bonds anyway lured by high returns. When Yes Bank collapsed under fraud and financial irregularities, the RBI was forced to undertake a bail-out exercise. The bonds were extinguished as part of this process.

For Yes Bank’s AT1 bond investors, the SC judgment is a clear win. But, for the banking regulator, this is a case of the judiciary encroaching on its turf and undermining its authority.

AT1 bonds are, by design, instruments meant to be written down in the event of a bank collapse. This is perfectly within the rules. Investors must have known this while signing up for the bonds. When the judiciary intervenes and overturns such a write-down despite it being consistent with the applicable rules and contractual terms, it risks undermining the very purpose of these instruments. It could also create uncertainty about the enforceability of contracts and weaken the credibility of the regulatory framework.

As RBI argued in the court before, the investors cannot, on one hand, enjoy the benefit of a high interest rate by investing in such high-risk instruments, only to shift the onus of loss upon RBI when things go south. That’s not fair.