Trump’s oil U-turn is a reprieve, not a victory for India

Despite the relief, the big lesson for India is that its trade and energy interests remain vulnerable to Washington’s political moves
Cylindrical objects with Trump and Putin's pictures
Jørgen Håland/Unsplash
Published on: 

In a major U-turn, on October 16, US President Donald Trump ordered the waiver of specified tariffs, sanctions and restrictions under the Lindsey O Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act of 2026, bringing relief to Russian oil buyers including India. This decision came just days before October 18, when the 100% tariff would have applied to qualifying new purchases of Russian oil and gas.  

For India, this is a relief. Yet, the most important takeaway from Trump’s retreat on tariffs is not the relief itself, but the uncertainty that preceded it. US threatened with a punitive tool capable of inflicting serious damage on Indian exports before suspending at the last minute. The uncertainty remained over India throughout.

Hypothetically, if Trump had gone ahead with the additional duties of up to 100%, Indian exporters to the US could have faced a formidable disadvantage in their largest export market. Look at the numbers. India's exports to the United States in FY26 reached $87.3 bn. The US constitutes around 20% of India’s total exports.  

The fact is India’s Russian oil purchases (30-44%) were driven by commercial considerations and energy security. As a country dependent on imports for more than 85-88% of its crude requirements, India cannot afford to treat energy sourcing as an instrument of geopolitical alignment alone. Cheaper Russian crude offered refiners an opportunity to contain costs and limit pressure on the import bill.

Nor is it economically wise to abandon a supplier simply because the US disapproves, particularly when global energy markets remain vulnerable to geopolitical disruption. Diversification is important. Replacing one dependency with another is not. The point is India should resist the temptation to treat the latest US reprieve as a diplomatic success but a warning signal.

More importantly, the India-US trade deal is yet to reach finality. At this point, the threat of punitive tariffs has demonstrated how easily this commercial relationship can become hostage to disagreements over issues that extend well beyond trade. India shouldn’t let that happen.

India must therefore seek a middle ground — keep negotiating with Washington and seek a durable trade arrangement while preserving the freedom to make energy decisions on commercial interest grounds. That is primarily a diplomatic task.