“This is unprecedented”: India’s fledgling cyber insurance sector gets a reality check

Cyber insurance covers and claims are rising, even as stakeholders grapple with ever-evolving risks and murky legalese
A green lock
TSD Studio/Unsplash
Published on: 

Cyber insurance claims are rare for Policybazaar. But recently, within a 10-15 day window, the insurance marketplace received eight claim applications. The claimants included a bank, a fintech company, an IT services firm, a logistics company, and a travel aggregator.

"This is unprecedented," Evaa Saiwal, Policybazaar’s practice head for liability, credit, and specialty risk told The Financial Standard.

India’s apex cyber emergency agency CERT-In had seen it coming. On November 4, the agency had warned financial-sector entities about an AI-assisted threat actor it called Crafty Falcon. This was a follow-up on an October 9 warning on attacks exploiting payment and disbursement APIs. 

The threat, CERT-In had announced, was active and ongoing. It was still receiving reports of successful attacks, including at non-banking financial companies (NBFC) and fintechs that had been alerted earlier and had undertaken remediation.

Some of these companies had left remediation incomplete. They were attacked again. The incursions were timed to coincide with holidays and weekends, when monitoring was lax.

Corporate cybersecurity risks are becoming more insidious, and they are triggering a sudden buzz in India’s fledgling cyber insurance sector.

Banks, among the most vulnerable, are buying more cover than ever. But conversations with insurers, brokers, lawyers, and bankers reveal a more complex picture. 

Insurance packages are growing larger, but individual insurers are servicing thinner slices of the pie. The industry has barely begun identifying the common technology vendors whose failure could hit several banks at once. And lawyers say the language that decides whether a loss is paid has not been tested in Indian courts.

Will the policy wording hold? How will losses be divided between insurers? And will insurers even pay? Answers to these critical questions remain fuzzy. With demand rising rapidly, the industry needs to solve the puzzle on the fly.

"How much can we get?"

Tanuj Galani, president of Prudent Insurance Brokers, says buyers of cyber covers in India have evolved in three stages. In 2014, when cyber insurance was first introduced, customers asked whether they should buy. After the pandemic, they asked how much. 

Now, he said, the question is: "How much can we get?”

Large banks typically buy limits of ₹500 crore to ₹1,000 crore, Galani said. Many are looking at doubling this, some going even higher. "It's not an incremental change now," he said.

Behind this rush is a big number mandated by new regulation. The Digital Personal Data Protection Act stipulates penalties of up to ₹250 crore for firms failing to maintain reasonable security safeguards. Galani expects the law to take effect in May 2027. 

This 250-crore figure is weighing on CXOs’ decision of how much insurance to buy, Galani said, cautioning that it is not an accurate way to calculate cover.

The country’s largest private sector bank by assets, HDFC Bank, says it follows a more calibrated path. Sameer Ratolikar, group head and chief information security officer (CISO), said the bank has raised limits gradually over several years, using a model to estimate value at risk and studying peer limits at home and abroad. 

In written responses, Ratolikar called the bank's cover "sufficient to cover the prevailing risks."

Cyber programmes in India are largely reinsured, either through annual treaties or case-by-case placements. The market is growing from a small base. Najm Bilgrami, head of Casualty and Financial Lines Product at insurer Tata AIG, put the corporate cyber insurance market at about ₹1,000 crore, with premiums growing 22%-25% a year over the past three years. Bilgrami expects this growth to continue.

Bigger limits, however, do not mean bigger bets by each insurer. Bilgrami said insurers Insurers that were offering ₹150 crore-₹200 crore coverage to a single bank two years ago are now shrinking that by half. By spreading their capacity across multiple banks, they reduce their exposure to a large loss at any one bank.

That means programmes need more participants. Galani said a programme running to several hundred crores typically involves five to seven insurers, a lead and several followers. He said more than 10 insurers offer cyber cover in India. That competition, he said, holds prices down.

A general insurer said on condition of anonymity that from 2020 to 2023, cyber insurance premiums grew 70%-80% a year. The market has softened since because capacity has increased. Demand for cyber policies is rising, but premium growth has slowed to 20%-30%.

To be sure, there are disagreements within the industry on pricing. 

Galani claims he has seen no “worrisome” change in rates at scale. Saiwal said this year's renewals were done at much lower rates, with some quotes at 0.2%-0.3% against no more than 0.5%-0.6% two years ago, and that Indian insurers reprice only after they pay out. "The books are going to take a hit," she said. Bilgrami rejected the blanket claim that premiums have not risen, saying prices jump after four or five large incidents and ease when things settle.

Everyone interviewed for this piece agreed prices will shoot up overnight if, given the growing spectre of , a couple of catastrophic losses land on insurers’ desk. Saiwal expects insurers to be less willing to cut prices at December renewals, with a possible revision when reinsurance treaties renew from April.

“Premiums may start rising in six months,” said Suvendu Prusty, founder-director of insurtech platform Riskcovry.

Third-party risks on the rise

The worst-case scenario that is keeping insurers up at night is not one large claim, but many arriving at once. "Aggregation of risk is the most difficult [challenge] to solve for right now," Galani said. One event can hit several companies, and trigger several coverages under the same policy.

Contingent business interruption, where the insurer pays when a critical supplier is attacked, magnifies this risk in banking, where much work is outsourced to IT vendors.

Bilgrami said India has not seen such an aggregated exposure event in the last 10 years but called the concern "very genuine", pointing to the 2024 CrowdStrike outage that disrupted multiple airlines and hospitals in a single day. Very few Indian insurers have started counting how many common service providers sit across their portfolios, he said. There are exceptions like Tata AIG, which has begun mapping common service providers such as large cloud and telecom providers.

Attacks exploiting vulnerabilities in third-party vendors are increasingly on banks’ minds. AU Small Finance Bank said late October it was investigating a possible leak of vehicle-loan customer data from a Salesforce-hosted platform. HDFC Bank lists API and supply-chain attacks among its main risks. Its third-party risk unit audits vendors at regular intervals, runs awareness sessions, checks baseline and regulatory compliance, and puts "toll gates" on communication between third parties and the bank, CISO Ratolikar said.

Murky legalese

If a common technology vendor suffers a cyberattack, lawyers expect disputes over whether the resulting losses across several banks should be treated as one incident or multiple events.

Supreme Court advocate Tushar Kumar said a systemic cyberattack affecting multiple financial institutions could expose insurers and reinsurers to competing interpretations of aggregation clauses, event definitions and liability limits. Determining whether multiple losses constitute a single occurrence or separate insured events could become particularly contentious.

Nupoor Maharaj, Advocate, Delhi High Court, said insurers and reinsurers may disagree over how claims are grouped and which limits apply. While bank might believe their cover is sufficient, lawyers say sufficiency depends on wording. Kunal Sharma, managing partner at TARAksh Lawyers and Consultants, said a transfer authorised by staff deceived by a deepfake can fall between the cyber policy's "voluntary parting" exclusion and the Bankers' Blanket Bond, leaving no policy that responds. 

Maharaj said such a transfer may qualify only under a specific fraud extension with its own cap and requirements.

Sharma flagged further gaps. Customer compensation under RBI's limited-liability framework is a regulatory obligation rather than adjudicated liability and may fall outside third-party insuring clauses. DPDP penalties are covered only "where insurable by law", which is untested in India. "Where insurable by law" refers to the legal requirement that an insurance contract must have an insurable interest to be valid.  State-backed attack exclusions turn cover into a contest over attribution, where the insurer bears the burden but may lack the evidence. And CERT-In's six-hour reporting rule can collide with insurers' prior-consent conditions if responders act first.

India has little case law on any of this, but one dispute shared by a lawyer shows how murky things can get. The matter involved a payments company, where the Delhi High Court sent the dispute to arbitration without ruling on whether the claimed loss was insured. Since a majority of the claims are being rejected on the basis of unclear modus operandi of these incidents, such disputes will likely increase.

Adaptability on trial

"Typically, a company identifies a risk, buys an insurance policy for it, and then sits tight for 12 months, hoping nothing happens,” Galani says. “But with cyber risks, [the scenario] can change quickly, sometimes within the year.”

Take contingent business interruption, for instance. Say this cover wasn’t available at the start of January but became available in June. Should a company wait until renewal to review its cover, or make changes mid-term? And how will it keep track of what needs to change?

"Are customers doing enough to stay aware of changing insurance needs during the policy period? The answer is no,” says Galani. “There’s a lot of work to be done. Cybersecurity teams are continually adapting, but that does not happen with insurance. That needs to change.”

Some insurers have now started moving beyond a traditional indemnity-based approach, working with policyholders through the year to strengthen their cybersecurity preparedness. Bilgram says, "We [organise] training for clients, including phishing simulations and cybersecurity training. We share areas where threat actors are targeting organisations so clients can identify gaps and address exposures in their networks."

December's renewals and April's reinsurance treaties will show whether the claims now arriving are a blip or the start of repricing. They will also show whether banks' bigger covers pay out when an attack hits, and whether insurers' thinner slices can absorb it.